One of my top three. The only things that bother me are the crop on the right and the left. Cutting off the boats is usually not a good thing. I love the border and the tones in this image. One of my top three. 10
Wonderul take on the challenge. I am not sure if the washed out sky works here, it pulls the readers eye too much instead of focusing on the sailboats.
I like high contrast but this is pumped up a bit too high even for me. Sky lacks detail to the point that it almost looks unatural against the richness of tone and contrast below. Like the content though.