Author Thread
04/20/2003 01:33:18 AMPost actions
Hello from the critique club! :)
This is a very interesting approach to the challenge. I like the originality in thinking.
The background is wonderful: clean, clear and give the impression the walnuts are floating.
The composition is nice. I like that the walnuts are not all in the center. The bottom weight of the photo is appealing.
The lighting seems a little off. The little bits are dark and not well focused. It detracts from an otherwise well done photo.
Photographer found comment helpful.
Comments Made During the Challenge
04/12/2003 05:08:10 PMPost actions
Are you sure it's 3.1415.... ?
Photographer found comment helpful.
04/12/2003 12:29:24 PMPost actions
Interesting photo. I like the lighting on this, and the background is nice. The subject matter isn't highly aesthetically pleasing, though.
Photographer found comment helpful.
04/11/2003 12:41:21 PMPost actions
I originally gave this a 7, but I'm bumping it up to a 9, because I keep looking at it. I think it's clever and demonstrates pi very well. Not only that, I like its whimsy, and the lighting and composition are marvelous. Nice work! Hey too bad they're not pecans. We could have had pecan pi!
Photographer found comment helpful.
04/11/2003 03:15:52 AMPost actions
If I stand correct this is 3.1415926535_9_ but hey, close enough. But what a idea!
Photographer found comment helpful.
04/09/2003 11:39:05 PMPost actions
Very original. decent focus, but maybe a touch more DOF to detail the 0.1415 guys. I would like to see just a hint of light on the darker side to...just a touch.
Photographer found comment helpful.
04/09/2003 10:57:23 AMPost actions
Obscure without the title.
Photographer found comment helpful.
04/09/2003 04:47:51 AMPost actions
This CRACKs me up! ;-) Pun intended.
Photographer found comment helpful.
04/08/2003 11:22:59 PMPost actions
Very good and unique representation. I also like the lighting.
Photographer found comment helpful.
04/07/2003 02:20:04 PMPost actions
Reading left to right 3.14 would have been perfect. Excelent picture. Very, very imaginative.
Photographer found comment helpful.
04/07/2003 10:23:43 AMPost actions
wow. nice colored walnuts, and the pieces are cute too. good lighting also, good focus too.
Photographer found comment helpful.
04/07/2003 12:39:24 AMPost actions
Great photo, but a stretch for "PI" without the title.. 7
Photographer found comment helpful.