Author Thread
Post actions
A normal picture for sunset. Nothing unsual
Post actions
Comments Made During the Challenge
Post actions
Very pretty sunset. Unfortunately, without the title I don't find anything within the shot itself that meets the challenge.
Post actions
Using the title to meet the challenge? Nice idea!
Post actions
yeh i dont think this is gonna be acceptable, nice shot but it doesnt represent five.
Post actions
I'll take your word that it was shot right then, but the picture itself (while very nice) doesn't in any way convey 'five' to me.
Post actions
This is a lovely sunset photo, but it doesn't meet the challenge in my opinion. I can't see nothing in it related to the number 5.
Post actions
Post actions
but how do we really know it was at 5:05?
Post actions
Sorry but that is stretching the challenge too far.
Post actions
unfortunately, i feel this image lacks enough details, and in terms of challenge theme, although I'd like to think that i'm not a theme fascist, there's a bit of a reach required here. the title says a lot, but i'd want more resonance between what the image presents and the challenge theme here.
Post actions
This is a nice picture, but unfortunately needs the title to make any sense in terms of the challenge. Most voters vote down photos that rely on the title to correlate with the challenge.
Post actions
I'm not even seeing five in this, but it's a nice pic. Kinda disqualifies it in my book.
Post actions
But this could be some other time, some other date. No numbers in this one.
Post actions
Post actions
Post actions
Except for the title, I don't see it meets the challenge. Nice sunset though.
Add photograph to your favorites
Add photographer to your favorites
Photographer found comment helpful.
