Author Thread
Post actions
thanks a lot for all your helpful comments!
Comments Made During the Challenge
Post actions
i like this. how did you get the rose to get out of focus, yet stay so bright.??
Post actions
Very well done great detail and very crisp.
Post actions
Post actions
Surreal look in the middle part of the rose - very nice. I think it coul dhave been composed more tightly to eliminate some of the background.
Post actions
Very beautiful! I would like to see how a closer crop on the rose would look, but the framing suits this well - 8 - Mav
Post actions
I rellay like the soft focus for this picture. Great texture
Post actions
Love the rose colour, love the shallow DOF, don't like the colour of the border.
Post actions
This is very nicely composed, and nicely lit. Even the extreme softness overall works nicely.
Post actions
Lovely shot...delicate and ethereal.
Post actions
Post actions
Lovely macro, the colours looks so pastel-like, and soft and dreamy. Good job.
Post actions
Nice bright color. Nicely composistioned.
Post actions
Beautiful shot of a beautiful Rose. Lovely color. Good focus. Good lighting. Visual impact is appealing and has good quality, and in MHO you were heading for a really splendid comment and high score, so why in the heck did you go and crop off the bottom petal??
Post actions
The color looks too soft. over saturated in the bottom left corner.
Post actions
This is awesome. I think it looks like a painting somehow. Great lighting, and I like the background...it is kinda fuzzy, giving it a much softer and delicate look. The bottom left is a little bright. Like I said, this is awesome.
Post actions
Post actions
This one definitely meets the color challenge as color dominates the photo, but roses are a pretty common subject so the competition is pretty stiff with this subject. The soft focus is a tad strong for my taste. I am also distracted by the dark edge of the bottom left petal. Composition and use of color are very good in this picture and I also really like the background (especially the top left section of it). Finally I don’t care for the border on this picture. Good effort, I gave it a 5.
Post actions
I like this rose close ups work good on flowers
Post actions
looks over saturated and too soft
Post actions
Very well done. Really like the soft focus here
Post actions
nice image, bright, vibrant, and clear good work
Post actions
Lovely shot... greatly done!
Post actions
Post actions
Post actions
Post actions
If you were to crop the photo in the center, it'd be more effective and gets rid of the other elements that are distracting.
Add photograph to your favorites
Add photographer to your favorites
Photographer found comment helpful.
