Lovely location you found here, I don´t think there is anything wrong with this shot at all, good clarity, sharpness, colours and contrast. I just don´t find it very interesting, that´s all. Also, I can´t help but wonder what the rest of the lake looks like, without having a clue on what is to the right of the frame here I desperatly want to find out and I feel when I am looking at this as this is just the left half of the shot and you cut out the right half. Anyway, still way better than most shots in the challenge and very well technically done, I gave it an 8.
This is my second go-around =) - Definately a picture that matches it's title! I would love to be there!!! Excellent photo! The reflections in the water is beautiful and what a perfect sky! Your exposure is better than perfect! And I love your composition. I just bumped you from a 7 to 10. =) I only wish that random thing in teh water at the river's bend was cloned out (but that's a VERY minor detail) =)