Awesome image! It's so smooth, it's almost unreal. Great lighting and composition, it's nice and simple and fits the challenge well. Minimal in color and complexity of texture, this is a winner in my mind.
A very interesting take on this challenge, I like how the bottle has changed color and shape to play upon our expectations of what a coke bottle should look like.
this is very intriguing, almos tlooks like a negative of the coke bottle, though im not sure whats going on with the bottle neck. Cool lighting, I think it works well here. 7
Idon't know why i like this. its not the nuetral gray dead space with the banding in the gradient caused by the drop off from the light or the tricked out coke bottle.. it must be bothe and all together a good presentation.
Don't know WHERE you found this bottle, but I love it! What a great subject! Good gradient in the background and I think you chose a background color that really compliments the subject. The lighting seems a little extreme on the label of the bottle, but other than that, great!
I'm struggling to see how this falls into basic editing? unless you're photographing an already manipulated image of a coke bottle? Or of course I could just be missing the point completely :)
Composition is good, but IMHO it would have been even better if you would have left a little bit more space to the left of the bottle so that all of the side of the bottle is in the frame. Also I don“t really care for inverted shots, it hurts your image more than helps it at least for me personally.
Inverted and solarized? Wonderful technique to camoflauge the bottle and achieve this fluid effect. Nice, sharp image with lots of detail and processing which didn't introduce any distracting artifacts. Very abstract...I like abstract.
There's a lot of negative space, but I feel it doesn't quite come across as minimalistic (you could merely crop the right two-thirds of the frame and still have basically the same photo). I'm sure a lot of creativity and thought went into this photo and I won't deduct on this basis. Overall a solid 7.