This is a beautiful shot. It's a pity that the challenge topic forced you to include the stuff in the bottom left corner. The image is much stronger without it.
Beautiful landscape and wonderful reflection. The only thing I want to point out is that the view is so great that the phototgrapher that should be the main subject re. the rules of this challenge gets almost lost there in the corner. Great shot though!
Awesomely beautiful image, but doesn't quite meet the challenge. Your 'subject' is supposed to be the mountain or the little tiny person jammed down in the corner? If it's the mountain, it takes up a large portion of the images pixels. If it's the little man, he isn't 'the strong point of the image'.
Great capture anyways!
TC
To me, this seems like a "Where's Waldo" shot, that the mountains and lake are the subject, not the photographer. I like the photo a lot, though. The reflections are beautiful and you've got nice contrast and composition here.
Beautiful scenery and you nailed the theme with the person there. It's a bit too grainy and there is a spot on the mountain on the left that should be fixed with cloning.
Gasp! What a BEAUTIFUL mountain scene. The reflection is amazing. You must have captured this pretty early in the morning. I wonder where this is. I like your little minimalist photographer in the corner :)
the strong point of this image to me is the mountains and they are the largest thing in this photo. I see how the guy is very minimal, but I dont think that he is the actual subject of the photo. That being said, I give it an 8 because it does meet the challenge a heck of alot better than most of these entries!
Lovely shot - best I've voted on so far. Have you tried using a program called NeatImage to help get rid of the grainyness of the sky and it's reflection? The demo is free to download. (there's also a dot centre-left... dust on the lens?) 7/10
The scene is beautiful, but the subject is out of focus. If the focus had been reversed, with the photographer sharp and the mountains very out of focus, it would have been much more interesting.
This is a pretty grand photo. Although the object was to catch the photographer (who takes a very small part of the entire image) I am drawn to the grand and beautiful mountains and trees and lake. Would be an incredible image WITHOUT the photographer in it...But not for this challenge of course. <5>