Author Thread
Post actions
Great reflection of the hand. The red is very effective against the gold of the metal pull. Like it alot!
Post actions
Well, the score for the hand in the ball is 24 comments in favor and 10 comments opposed (at least counting those comments that explicitly mention the hand).
Message edited by author 2005-05-04 12:12:58.
Comments Made During the Challenge
Post actions
The reflection of the hand is distracting for me. 5
Post actions
The reflected hand makes this more interesting
Post actions
Clever idea. For me the reflection of the hand is a bit of a distraction. But even with that I think this is a 9.
Post actions
great, except the hot spot is a little distracting
Post actions
Very nice, too bad you couldn't do anything about the hand reflection. Unless, of course, you put it there on purpose.
Post actions
strong image - and then the hand pulls you in even deeper. like it a lot.
Post actions
I love the reflection in the ball. Nice work!
Post actions
Post actions
Post actions
The reflected hand makes the picture here! Good idea.
Post actions
I like this photo a lot. The only thing I am not sure about is the hand in the reflection but i guess you were trying to show that you were going to turn it off? Otherwise I really like. 8 from me...
Post actions
After coming to this image a second time to make comment...I just noticed the hand i the reflection......My vote of 5 still stayes the same because the subject matter is voiceless....( yes I know this is subjective)
Post actions
Very clever, the hand is definatly a nice touch
Post actions
The hand reflection totally makes this shot stand out. Great thoughtful work.
Post actions
Post actions
I really liked this shot, great job with the reflection and lighting
Post actions
Post actions
interesting use of theme, nice lighting, nice gradience of bg, whites need work, blacks ok
Post actions
great comp, i love the reflection in the ball
Post actions
NOt sure if I like the hand in the refelction or not. Nice shot though, good lighting.
Post actions
Nice shot. I like the reflection of the hand in the ball.
Post actions
Color and lighting great. I don't care for reflected hand. A 7.
Post actions
One of the best in this challenge
Post actions
Love the colors and how the background fades. Plus the hand reflection. I gave it a 7.
Post actions
Nice image. I like how you used the reflection in the image as well.
Post actions
whats with the reflection of the hand in the ball?
Post actions
The hand is a bit distracting, good pic
Post actions
So simple, and yet so well done! I liked this shot right off the bat, but it wasn't until I looked closer that I noticed the reflection of the hand. In my mind, that bumped it up from a 9 to a 10. Very well done.
Post actions
Very creative with asking hand.
Post actions
the hand makes it !
Post actions
Great idea to add the reflection of the hand.
Post actions
one of my top choices your photo draws the viewer in to a wonderful place...the backround warms and invites you to come to the subject which holds and extra added surprise...best of luck ....9
Post actions
Very well done. I love the reflection of the hand.
Post actions
I love the reflection of the hand. Nice touch. One of my favorites
Post actions
I didn't see the hand right away - nice!
Post actions
Nice i like the whay you could see the hand there
Post actions
I like the ball and the chain, not to sure about the hand though
Post actions
Very Kewl. Nice colors, but in my mind, it might have been better without the reflection of the hand in the finial. <6>
Post actions
Nice touch with the reflection of the hand.
Post actions
clean and cool, the reflection of the hand is grate
Post actions
Post actions
the reflection in the ball is not quite spot on - shame
Post actions
An interesting concept. The fading color of the background offsets the tedium, and the hand in the reflection draws the eye. My only real complaint is that the reflected highlights are distracting and make the reflected hand a little hard to look at.
Add photograph to your favorites
Add photographer to your favorites
Photographer found comment helpful.
