The sensor grain is a bit distracting.I think that I would have preferred this shot without the moon. I seldom like shots which include the moon, since it always looks too small in photographs unless it's the only item in the picture.
you had me on this one until i scrolled down and saw the rest of the photo. was excellent when it was the moon alone, crop the bottom of the photo out.
I like the tones in the sky a lot and find the picture to be pleasing overall. The composition works very well for me but I don’t think the scene is strong enough to really hold my attention for very long.
Strong work to retain that ddetail in the moon; and I like also that your chosen landscape is so very plain. I don't like, for this challenge, the enormous graininess of the sky, however: it seems to go against the 'full control' element that is so often a hallmark of minimalism. But it's an interesting approach, certainly.
This is a nice image. I really like the fact that you shot this image in black and white. It adds contrast. I also like where you positioned the moon in your photograph. Nice work.
This is great! This is just what I had in my mind for a "mimimalism" picture. B/W is a good choice here. Just a little mottled for my likes, but not in an ugly way. It looks natural and not over processed. 7