Interesting response you got from many as regards her age and nudity. I am also one who finds nudity among children often inappropriate, but I don't find that to be the case here. For me this is in no way sexual. It conveys innocence for me. For me, nudity in and of itself is not ugly and wrong; the morality of it for me boils down to intent (or perceived intent). I have been offended by nudish shots of children before (in fact, there's one in the current lighting challenge), but I hope we're not so sensitized that we throw the good out with the bad.
Sally Mann caused quite a stir about 20 years ago for her controversial images of her own children, often unclothed. YOu can check out some of her work here:
//www.art-forum.org/z_Mann/gallery.htm
edited to add: the neat image or other noise reduction technique is taken to far for me in this shot.
This is a wonderful shot... I love the inosence of the girl... Seems so quite and peaceful... I would agree that this should've gottan a better place... Very nicely done... I Love this shot... Keep on doing the great work...
Seems by a comment or two as well as about half the entries, a lot of people thought you had to have rock, paper, AND scissors in this challenge. Not so!
This shot finished well, but I honestly think it should've done better.
I normally don't care for obviously "posed" shots, but this one is certainly an exception to that rule. Beautiful imagery and perfect lighting. It really cries out "innocence" against a cold, hard environment. Well done.
really really nice. I have added this to my favourites. I love the softness, its very angelic. Think this could earn you a ribbon...well done and good luck. A definate 10 from me
would be a little better if her hair covered the wings strap. Not a huge fan of pictures of kids in cloths (or lack there of) like this but will not mark down my personal beliefs. Good luck