Critique Club Comments by Grayce
Nice concept here! The contrasts provide a lot of interest.
I think that a sharper focus would serve this well, mainly because of the extreme opposite of the black and white. In other words, the contrast would be stronger if sharper. Softer focus doesn't enhance contrast too well.
Anyway, I do like this image. It seems to fit the challenge well.
The lighting was well handled with no harsh reflections. The composition is very good.
There is no noise or digital artifacts, congrats! With black that isn't easy.
Nice work!
Regards,
Great contrasts, and a nice example of symmetry. Lighting on the left side seems a bit off, though-- noticeable on the left edge and the bottom of the glass. Black fluid is just a tiny bit lower than the white one, but overall, a very striking shot.
This looks like the negative vs. the symmetrical. a nice concept still and I like the style that this was taken. It looks like its from the '20s or something. Good image but not really symmetrical
Recommned for disqualification.. There is no reflection of either of the glasses in either glass.. sorry, I will check back and comment appropriately on it if I am proved wrong.. If it is genuine though I will give you a 7 for this... (marked as 7 in advance of admins decision)
Add photograph to your favorites
Add photographer to your favorites
Photographer found comment helpful.
