The colour here are fantastic, for me thought the link to theme of rock, paper, scissors is a bit of a stretch. However as a straight photograph this is excellent.
A truly beautiful photo! I think it deserves a high rating, though I would go even higher if the existance of rock was more evident. But it's hard not to appreciate the beautiful colors captured in this shot.
I don't believe that's a rock silhouette, looks like trees to me. :-O Nice sunset though. Maybe if the challenge were "Sunset, Paper, Scissors" you get better than a 5 from me.
:-(
I think this is stretching the challenge a bit too far, mainly because it's hard to even see the rock. Okay, I know it's there and it's a really good picture, but this should have gone to free study. 8.
VERY nice shot but I don“t see anything about this shot that fits into the theme so I only gave it a 4 but if this had been in free study I would probably have given it a 7-8.
This is beautiful and will come close to winning this challenge. Some will find the exaggerated saturation and what appears to be huge amounts of NI overpowering, but to be honest I quite like the effect. My main qualm with this image is that it's a little hard to consider what appears to be an island with trees growing on it to be a rock.
This is an absolutely beautiful shot... unfortunately, I'm not sure exactly what you're referring to by "rock", unless you mean the edge of land (island?), and I don't really consider that applicable.