Author Thread Comments Made During the Challenge
Post actions
The tents are distracting, a closer crop on the bottom would eliminate them and still maintain your "Y"
Post actions
The tree looks maybe too sharpened...not sure but more detail in the shadow areas and a little less contrast overall would have made this super nice.
Post actions
I love the shadows. I think the tents are a bit too busy. but i do like the picture
Post actions
clever title.. almost enough to make me give you a full point more than I'm going to.
Post actions
Looks a little over-sharpened.
Post actions
The weird white glow around everything makes this look over-processed.
Post actions
Interesting technique.. Pretty average shot and fairly boring Y. However the technique you used to make this high contrast B&W shot realy took the plain shot and stepped it up a knotch. Great job.
Post actions
The tents really take the focus of the photo away from the tree.
Post actions
seems oversharpened to me, I don't care for the outline that appears around the tree, maybe that was your intent to make the letter stand out more, but I find that it distracts from the overall photo, also the tents on the bottom are very distracting, maybe it could have been taken from and angle that would have made them less obtrusive?
Post actions
good image, i have seen quite a few trees with a 'Y' in it
Post actions
Post actions
I think this is oversharpened - otherwise a good on challenge image.
Add photograph to your favorites
Add photographer to your favorites
Photographer found comment helpful.
