Nice grouping - makes this one a little different (maybe a little too blue, but that's nitpicking!) What I especially liked was the area you cleared for the duck's swimming - it pulled my eye away from all the other props to the real Star-of-the-Show.
A conventional look for an unconventional challenge, which leads to an unexpected and refreshing entry. Wish I could see more of the ducy's reflection in the bath, but the soft focus adds to the mood. Good job.
Beautiful - one of my favorites - would have like something else to be a little sharper - but I like the way the duck is in the background but still meets the rules
You had a good idea, but I'm not too fond of the execution. Your picture is quite noisy, some more light would have been good. Also, the ducky is very small. 5.
Good job integrating the elements into a coherent scene.The white balance seems off, and the composition is bottom-heavy, but this is one of the few shots where grapes and a rubber ducky co-exist in a scene that makes sense.
Entire picture looks slightly out of focus, probably b/c it was dim where you took the pic. Candle flames are overexposed. If you've got photoshop you can "darken highlights" to help fix that.
Ah, a picture that is not centered on the quacker. I think it would have been better if the focus was on the plate though since the duck has been reduced to a background object.