Aw, Murphy is adorable! Love ths shot, very nice. The highlight on his head is nice but casts a bit blue, was that meant to be? Slightly crooked, leaves me tilting my head. In the last minute I raise you from a 7 to an 8!
The harsh lighting lessens the appeal for an otherwise wonderful image. I think this dog fits perfectly on this porch - its a great 'backdrop.' 7 but lighting improvement would have gotten a 9 from me.
This is my second go-around =) - Awh... very cute! I would only suggest cropping it so it doesn't look like Murphie's about to slide down hill =) I would have also left a little more space to the left and possibly the top. However, overall I think you did a really great job!
The lighting is a bit harsh. It makes it a bit hard to make out the eyes. Nice pose and the background works for me because it seems appropriate. Very pretty dog.