Wow-really all I can say is flipping through to find mine and I see yours finishing here..no way this shot is awesome! I gave it a 9..for sure a ribbon as far as I'm concerned, but more importantly probably the most beautiful shot in this challenge. Adding to my favourites.
Without the title it is hard to immediately see what this is, which isn't good for stock images. The ice is in focus, but the colour, due to shadow or time of day
leaves me wanting more context in the frame. This might have more merit as art than stock.
This is a confusing picture on first and second glance. Actually I don't like all around. But I think you were close to something special with the ice and reflection.
I like this as an image for it's color and patterns. Took a minute to figure out what it was (kind of), still not really sure what it is exactly (ice and a puddle?).