Nice idea (though probably less obvious for us non-US citizens). I don't like the colour cast in the shadow, and wonder if using greater depth of field might not have focussed attention on the subject matter. Colours appear a little blown on the mustard bottle.
How can you honestly enter a photo of these 2 bottles of sauce for a 'best friends' challenge? if you are trying to get a brown ribbon you may be in luck!
Technically the subjects are too central in the image, also there is shadow from the lighting behind which does not look good. The background also does not help.
This is poorly set up, the shadows in the background detract from the overlit ketchup and mustard bottles. whats most detrating is the black scribbles on teh tile in front of the ketchup. cute idea but poorly done