Interesting concept and very good framing. I would have personally avoided the monochromatic tone. In a case like this, in my style, I would have made the red layer and then erased a part of the subject's clothing. Bumping up to 7 not because the image is surreal, but rather a nice study because of the subject matter.
Freaky shot. I like the idea, unforutnatly, the lighting is kind of a turnoff for me, as it doesn't offer any details or contrast of any kind. Also the background is a bit dull (behind fence). Not what i'd call surrealim, but close. 5