Author Thread
Post actions
This is so incredibly beautiful! It takes my breath away! I don't know how I've missed finding this -- either in the challenge -- or in all my poking around in the profiles -- but I'm glad I noticed it now! It's going straight to my favorites folder!
Post actions
Post actions
It is a gorgeous photo, but I'm curious to know what element of this picture was surreal for you?
Post actions
Hey eric: glad to see your image make the top 5. Congratulations, yet again.Message edited by author 2005-03-19 12:23:29.
Post actions
Wow, beautiful! Congrats!!!
Post actions
I thought this one would go blue..but a strong finish neverthelesss...congrats!
Post actions
Very nice! I was hoping to see you in the top ten. Congratulations.
Post actions
wonderul image, and many congrats on the 6th placement
Post actions
Eric: Congratulations on your 6th placing. You pulled off a caper here. It is so hard to win with just the strength of good photography and you have done it. Congratulations again.
Comments Made During the Challenge
Post actions
A ribbon for Ansel Adams-- not sure how its gonna do in surreal--
Post actions
Beautiful, just beautiful. I hope that you also post the color version.
Post actions
Post actions
It seems you did this without dodging and burning. Good job. I think this would have been much more surreal if the horizon had been cropped off and the image flipped - making it look as if the stones were huge and hanging in the clouded sky.
Post actions
It's a beautiful shot -- truly stunning -- but I don't get what makes it surreal, honestly.
Post actions
wow.. that is surreal! what a wonderful job you have done capturing this! Outstanding.
Post actions
Post actions
stunning shot, very surreal ...10
Post actions
Beautiful. One of my favorites. Should ribbon.
Post actions
this will likely finish top 5.
Post actions
nice shot, but to real to me
Post actions
great flow! / chingon fluidez!
Post actions
I'd love to know where and how this picture was taken, it's excellent
Post actions
A very surreal effect which carries the imagination. More like a static but beauriful rendition. 7
Post actions
Gorgeous!!! I love the dreamy surreal feel of it, and the full tonal range it uses.
Post actions
Beautiful picture and composition. I could've used a little more sharpness to give more detail and texture to the rocks. unfortunatly, really not surrealism. 6
Post actions
Very nice! Good strong darks!
Post actions
beautiful! i think i actually just lost my breath......
Post actions
Very nice image, unfortunately not surreal for me.
Post actions
very nice shot. good use of basic editing to get a very dreamy look. well balanced as well. I might like to see it with half of the forground rocks on the bottom cropped out to help center the focus more and draw the eye more to the midground. But it's great how it is. 9
Post actions
Like something out of "Lord of the Rings." Very nice shot, I'm impressed
Post actions
Post actions
I would have given this a high score in the Ansel Adams challenge also.
Post actions
Really beautiful landscape, but I don't think it's surreal. 7
Post actions
Seeing this image, you get the sense that you've just entered in one of a Jules Vernes adventures, somewhere lost in a mysty island. Very good job.
Post actions
looks like a picture of an other planet. I like it very much
Post actions
Soft fog on hard rocks I like the effect. very surreal
Post actions
great use of long shutter speed!
Post actions
Post actions
Wow! This is a really gorgeous image 10
Post actions
Post actions
love this photo my favorite 9
Post actions
I have seen this effect with water flowing, but not fog. A 9.
Post actions
Pretty, moody, dreamlike. Yet it doesn't quite manage to pose the stark contradictions or reality-bending imagery of surrealistic painting.
Post actions
Now this photograph is surreal, in my opinion. Stunning contrast in b&w. Sharply focused rocks, with smooth flowing water. Perfect composition. Could be preceived as mountain tips with clouds floating around them.... I give this a 10! Very well done, fits the challenge.
Post actions
Ansel outtake? Beautiful and fantastic either way. 10.
Post actions
Add photograph to your favorites
Add photographer to your favorites
Photographer found comment helpful.
