You have a great image here which beautifully uses the full range of tones. I feel the border is a little too large and becomes a little overbearing..... but I do like the picture
Nice image, but the frame is too heavy. I know you were mostly trying to get rid of distracting elements, but the tight crop, especially at the bottom, leaves this image lacking something. My brain wants to see more of the foreground.
Composition: 9
Technical: 9, Very peaceful. Nice tone range
Appeal: 10, Shadows on tree are quite interesting
Challenge: 9, I think the border is a little too big, and takes space from the photo
Overall Calculated Average Score: 9
It's a bit too tight for me, but on the other hand it still seems to work. I like the soft grey tones of the tree and boat and how they contrast against the somewhat darker toned background. Especially the way the tree fills the shot is very good.
Add photograph to your favorites
Add photographer to your favorites
Photographer found comment helpful.
