Author Thread
Post actions
Great pic, Arancha! Congrats for an excellent work.
Post actions
Thank you everybody for your wonderful comments and votes. I have learnt a lot with this challenge :)
Comments Made During the Challenge
Post actions
I like the layout but I think the contrast is too high.
Post actions
Post actions
Beautiful! A tad oversharpened. Nice setting .. 9
Post actions
This may have a little too much contrast but the composition is excellent. I like the dark sky as well.
Post actions
The whites seem blown out, but the effect is very nice.
Post actions
Trees on left seem oversharpened and perhaps too much contrast. I love the composition though which leads my eye from lower right around lake edge, to the upper right corner. Great reflections!
Post actions
This is an absolutely beautiful shot. My only critique is the loss of detail among the foreground shrub branches, but that's a minor distraction in an overall gorgeous photo.
Post actions
A beautiful image and a great entry to this challenge. The reflections on the water are superb. The contrast range seems just right and is very Adamsish. The lightness of the trees is awkward though but I'm sure a result of the way you processed the image. This is the look I was going for in my entry as well. You achieved it much better than I, and your final score will show it. I give you an 8. Very well done.
Post actions
To me, the trees on the left look a little too bright.
Post actions
Nice lake scene. Too bad about the blown highlights in the trees on the right.
Post actions
Composition: 9
Post actions
Very good picture. Don't know how you got tree with lots of leaves in this season. Picture will look better if trees were in focus.
Post actions
Beautiful composition and reflections
Post actions
excellent, I love it. If I could have just one thing, it would be to step to your left and leave the dead bush out. Still beautiful.
Post actions
Excellent photo, the reflections and framing really grab my attention. It just seems that the light on the trees in a bit overexposed.
Post actions
Post actions
Torn on this one. Solarized?! more than Adamized?! BOL 7
Post actions
The trees are kind of over exposed looking--lacking a little detail. Other than that, I like this shot!
Post actions
very nice. Great reflections.
Post actions
FIne be that way take all the good shots for yourself. Very nice.
Post actions
Strong image, nice flow with the water. Plenty of detail in all areas. Somehow I find the trees to the left a bit to bright.
Post actions
Post actions
Very cool editing, good composition and beautiful subject. Litle overdone maybe but still very nice.
Add photograph to your favorites
Add photographer to your favorites
Photographer found comment helpful.
