Author Thread
Post actions
Thanks for the comment. I knew it wouldn't finish that great but I really like picture and, in the end, I didn't want to submit a typical landscape. I'm actually happy with my score.
Post actions
I feel this should have been placed higher..it is very evocative of Adams' tree closeups..people didn't seem to like anything except the panoramas most of the time.
Comments Made During the Challenge
Post actions
Good texture study. Bumping up.
Post actions
I really like the sweeping lines of this.
Post actions
looks just a little soft. excellent photo though.
Post actions
Composition: 10, smooth and flowing lines are quite nice
Post actions
The light that helped capture this texture is just right. Great contrasts and lines!
Post actions
I love the texture and detail, the curves are wonderful..8
Post actions
My kind of subject, but I do feel that an deep DOF was essential here. Longer shutter and stopping down, while focusing on the furthest element, would have resolved this and given a real AA feel tot he composition - which is good but frustrating due to the focus.
Post actions
Excellent exposure and details!
Post actions
The lines and curves on this image are very nice. This photo looks very nice in BW and I love the shadowing effect created by the bark. 6
Post actions
exellent grain & tonalities
Post actions
very appropriate subject for the challenge - just a tinge soft, but I like the tonality and composition.
Post actions
Nice subject, the focus seems a little soft in the upper left corner.
Post actions
cracking texture shot - well done
Post actions
lovely lines and colours - congrats - gave it a 8
Post actions
The grain in this peice of wood was caught excellently... the depth is why i gave you a 10
Post actions
Post actions
A nice flowing subject with a good tonal range. Seems to lack sharpness in fore and background. -6
Post actions
Post actions
Very, very nice. Very much in the Weston/Adams mode, and you're to be commended for not exagerrating the contrast. It's a little lacking in critical sharpness, and the DOF is falling off upper left; an AA picxture would have both those under control. 9
Post actions
This is classic, and I think it to be a marvelous shot. The lines are simple and very engaging, and the tonal work is superb. 9
Add photograph to your favorites
Add photographer to your favorites
Photographer found comment helpful.
