Author Thread
Comments Made During the Challenge
03/08/2005 09:59:44 PMPost actions
light on white i cannot see it
a nice composition but i can't see how this meets the criteria
03/08/2005 08:39:58 PMPost actions
I am not one to get picky on "meeting the challenge", but have actually tried to get myself to pay more attention to it. It wouldn't be fair to those who did include a light color in their image to score this, a B & W, high. Sorry. This is a stunning image. EDIT: after so much variance in the interpretation of the challenge, I am coming back through and this time judging on photogrpahic quality only, and not if it meets the challenge within reason. Bumping up.
Photographer found comment helpful.
03/07/2005 09:46:07 PMPost actions
Background looks black to me
03/07/2005 06:27:38 PMPost actions
Nice photo, but I feel that the dark background defeats the idea of the challenge.
Photographer found comment helpful.
03/07/2005 01:02:34 PMPost actions
Nice picture, but I'm not sure it fits the challenge because the background is dark.
Photographer found comment helpful.
03/07/2005 12:18:47 PMPost actions
to me this is more of a black and white than a light color on white background as the challenge suggested.
Photographer found comment helpful.
03/06/2005 03:23:08 PMPost actions
Background much too dark. Love the idea of translucency. It would have been great on a whiter background
Photographer found comment helpful.
03/04/2005 12:14:22 AMPost actions
not to white of a background
03/03/2005 06:31:24 PMPost actions
Hummm...this almost seems to be the reverse of the challenge.
03/03/2005 05:21:28 PMPost actions
doesnt really fit the category, because its light on black.
03/03/2005 02:31:07 PMPost actions
A different take on this challenge, but equally effective. Very well lit, not overexposed. Beautiful image to look at. 10
p.s. the border could have been a bit thinner - it is quite strong when it's this wide.
Photographer found comment helpful.
03/03/2005 12:01:36 PMPost actions
The background might be a white sheet, but it doesn't look white.
Probably if the lighting source came from another direction.....
Photographer found comment helpful.
03/03/2005 12:28:44 AMPost actions
Hard to call the background white, at least to my eye.
Photographer found comment helpful.
03/02/2005 06:41:18 PMPost actions
Your deep shadows are an interesting interpretation of 'light on white'.
Photographer found comment helpful.
03/02/2005 06:03:57 PMPost actions
To my eye, this meets the challenge - nicely done.
Photographer found comment helpful.
03/02/2005 01:42:22 AMPost actions
Reminds me of a point that graphicfunk made about any given challenge implying its opposites-- he said something to the effect of: "In a 'Black' challenge, there is a place for a mostly white photo," though his phrasing was better. Great photo, but questionable border?
Photographer found comment helpful.
03/02/2005 01:25:57 AMPost actions
Either I need some serious calibration of my monitor or the background on this photo is anything but white.
Photographer found comment helpful.
03/02/2005 12:15:09 AMPost actions
Where's the white background?
Photographer found comment helpful.