This is a great photo. It's in honor of St. Patrick's day AND look ... it's green! Not the most breathtaking photo I've ever seen but clever nonetheless. Good choice of lighting, sharp focus. Overall a technically good photo. The only thing I would change to substitute a shamrock for the "garnish" :-)
This is so funny because I almost did an Irish Spring shot myself. I like this shot. It works for me. Would have also been a good entry for a Advertisement Challenge. Good luck with the challenge!
I heard once that females preferred the smell of Irish Spring over all other bars of soap. As for the image, it fits the theme pretty well. It's well framed, but I wish the leaves' colors weren't so different than the soap -- probably not much you could do about that, but they don't seem to blend well.
I like this fresh, clean, sharp focused and well lit shot. Simple idea well executed. This shows that less can be more! Very refreshing! Well done. -Clicker-
Very nice, clean (pun intended) product shot. I don't care for the surface it was photographed on, I would have liked a clean/smooth surface, but the composition is nice. Perhaps a little back lighting to get rid of the shadow on the top.
Composition is nice and simple
Idea is different/good originality
Fits the Challenge okay
Lighting is fine, bit of a shadow under the leaves
Focus looks okay
Colours are okay