out of focus and grainy.. doesnt really do anything for me. a tighter crop would of been slightly beneficial but to be honest the source photo didnt really give you a lot of scope to improve this during post-processing.
Nice attempt at the challenge. Maybe putting some white paper under the plate would have taken away the dark wood that Im finding a bit distracting. The photo is a little bit noisy, a lamp nearby the plate (out of the shot) could boost the available light and help get a clearer shot. Good effort, keep it up
Like your idea, but have a problem with the dark wood backround. I know you mean for the plate to be the background, but the wood being visable is a detraction.
focus is not very strong here, also I would have taken this so that the table were not vivible. A White paper to cover the whole background instead of the plate would have worked better.
This is really grainy. Perhaps you meant it to be, but I didn't care for it. The dark table also detracts from this "light on white" challenge, for me.
blurry, noisy, a blue cast and the dark table behind. i'm sure that with a white table, and another opportunity to take a steady shot you could have done better.