Critique Club Comments by Grayce
I love the detail you captured in this image. Really nice work! The background is good, and helps the subject to pop out. Photographing the frost on red buds was a good choice, since it adds just the right amount of color to bring it to life.
This doesn't typify a "From above" image, since it appears to be from the side. It could be, but doesn't give that impression. In the challenges it is important to adhere closely to the description of the challenge.
Anyway, it's really a nice picture and I'd be proud to have done it. Good work!
A tighter crop and sharper focus would greatly improve this shot. It is hard to tell is this is from above or the side - a point a reference is needed.
WOW, what can I saw, I really like it. It is my kind of image. Great focus and DOF. Others will likely critize the same qualities, but it works for me. Congratulations. 9 Morgan
Whilst this is a fabulous photo, in the context of the challenge it loses out a little for me in not clearly being 'from above': perhaps a little more detail in the background would have helped that - I'm not suggesting sharp focus, but perhaps a little more.
Beautifully captured and love the DOF throwing out the background.
I personally find that although I am happy to believe it's taken from above, visually it could just as easily be taken from the side - the image itself doesn't show the challenge has been met, even though I am sure it has.
For me the image has to show it too.
6, Kavey
Would be at least an 8 if I felt it met challenge better.
Add photograph to your favorites
Add photographer to your favorites
Photographer found comment helpful.
