The guy and the chair are marvellous and perfect for a subject on their own, but the background doesn't add up meaningfully. The other people are quite a bit of stretch so the image doesn't fit too well on this theme. I'd like to give you much higher number, but can't in this category. And you'll make the image better by reconsidering the tones on the ice (and border).
woow...is that u sitting on the ice there?.....man u freezed ur back there.....nice shot in a creative but painfull mode....very welldone
REGARDS
//www.photo.net/photodb/user?user_id=1185903
This is a great photo and technically it does relate to three but not as the main theme. If this was a free study I would have given it a 9 for this challenge an 8.
I like the way the three figures lead the eye back into the photo.
Those benches are unbelievable! Here in California that sort of thing is utterly unheard of.