Challenge: 6 I like the idea.
Composition: 5 I think going closer would have been nice
Technical: 5 I would have rather seen more of the stones and less of the background trees.
Appeal: 5 Just didnt do anything for me.
Overall: 5
It would be helpful if the picture were larger. I bet a lot of detail is lost because of the smaller size. It looks like it's got some great aspects to it, but it's hard to see at this size.