I can tell that there is supposed to be an Apple logo somehow transposed into this image, but it doesn't work too well, in my opinion. It's just sort of a burry blob that is a distraction. I'm not keen on the blue and black vertical objects on the left.
Challenge: 5 - I just dont see the old and new
Composition: 5 The blue on the left just isnt necessary
Technical: 5 Could have used better focusing
Appeal: 4 I'm just not getting wowed.
Overall: 5
It took me a second to realize what this was a picture of, but I like the creativity of reflecting off of an iPod case. I think contrasting the white of the iPod with a non-white object may have been more effective (say, with a black LP). I'm curious what this would have looked like if the iPod text was in focus also, with the background a bit blurry. (I thought of taking a picture of an iPod in front of some records, but your approach is more interesting.)