Yeah, I can notice the old one, this is very nice and very thoughtful for those banana lovers, well what would be cool is if the old one was rotton but that is my choice of a nice photo. Grear job, I don't see anything wrong with it. 9
I see one that is more ripe than the others. It's a stretch for me to call it old -vs- new though. For the challenge, not so good. As an image, well done, good use of light.
Even though the lighting is a bit dark, I think it works with the shot. In my opinion the bananas would have complimented the curves of the bowl if we saw them from the side. good job!