I really like your finished product and I gave this a 6. IMO, the editing is a bit heavy and obvious for a dpchallenge entry.
Again, I do like your treatment. :D
I really like this idea and the results you came up with.
One minor point is I'm not crazy about the title.
I did not vote this challenge but I would have voted 7-8.
very cool image...I would have preferred not seeing the wall meeting the molding on the right as it kinda points to perspective issues but the overall look of this is very appealing to me, Nice entry 8