This is one of those images that spoil the party, so to speak. I love it because it is a true slice of life and you managed to present it in its own aura of bleakness. A truly underrated image.
This got my highest score. It conveys a mood or a feeling better than any of the others. The color cast is a bit strong and it could use a bit more shapening, otherwise I would have given it a 10.
Appears as if you wanted soft focus but this looks out of focus. I like the contrast and the overall feeling of depression with the look of despair and color.