I gave the picture an 8 because I really, really like it. The profile view doesn't bother me at all. On the contrary: it adds an extra layer of intimacy to the portrait. Authenticity - you're absolutely right. I also love seeing his hand on the reins; it adds to the story.
I just wish there wasn't that other person in the background. It's okay since the hats don't overlap, but without it, I would have given you a 10. |