Author Thread
Post actions
Post actions
Congratulations on your achievement. I thought this would do well.
Post actions
Wonderful portrait shot Manny, congrats on the ribbon.
Post actions
its so good, very nice, congratulations
Post actions
Congratulations Manny...this is yet another stellar shot from you!!!! :o)
Post actions
Thought this was a great photo - but apparently there a 13 or so people who voted blindfolded !
Post actions
Manny, you are simply the best! Congratulatiosn. I just knew this would make it to the top. The both of you did such wonderfull job.
Post actions
Congratulations Manny! Beautiful entry.
Post actions
Congratulations on your Red Ribbon for this absolutly beautiful image. Very well deserved. Just wonderful!
Post actions
Manny, Manny, Manny... one day, just one day I'll head back to South-East Asia and we'll hook up and have a drink of Mekong Whiskey or a banana milkshake. Then we can play with our D70s!!!! :-D
Post actions
librodo, ur portraits have always amazed me, hope one day i can take images like this. Congrats on on yet another red ribbon!
Post actions
Congratulations on the ribbon and another excellent image.
Post actions
Many many thanks for the votes...i didn't expect to ribbon as there are many beautiful shots. I am here now in the Philippines for a vacation. This is a great Christmas present to me. Salamat.
Post actions
one of my top picks - quality photo.
Post actions
The "Master" does it again !
Post actions
you have so many second placers that should be first, no offence graphic your great but wow this is another great shot manny
Post actions
hataw ka talaga Manny!!! Congratulations.... :)
Post actions
Congratulations....
Post actions
You made the right choice. A wonderful entry. Congrats on your ribbon.
Post actions
Lovely shot, congrats on the ribbon.
Post actions
My favorite also -- just stunning!
Post actions
Great work as always Manny, congrats!
Post actions
My fave of the challenge by far! Great emotion in a simple shot.
Post actions
Well Manuel: A very touching image and I knew it was yours because of the quality and the authencity of feeling that the image conveys with expert lighting. Congratulations on your red.
Post actions
Yeah! way to go brother. what did you do...poke her with a sharp stick to make her cry? anything for the art I guess :)
are the king.
Comments Made During the Challenge
Post actions
I like this photo. I can't explain what it is I like about it but it's great.
Post actions
Is this another Librodo special ?? Whatever the case may be it's a ten from me. Intensely emotive portrait. Well done.
Post actions
Very emotive! You bring out the true broken hearted feeling in this photo. Great job.
Post actions
fine tonalities. The nearly vertical, elongated, left edge of the hand bothers me, especially inasmuch as it's very nearly in the center of the image. I like the slight upward tilt of the visible eye.
Post actions
I was going to try this image with my daughter but opted out at the last minute as portraiture is not my speciality..and after seeing this, I`m glad I did!!
Post actions
Nice job! Like your choice of subject! Fine tonal values!
Post actions
Returning for comments:
Post actions
Nice portrait, although the tear looks a little odd for some reason.
Post actions
I like the dark tones of this image as it suits the Brokenhearted feeling. The tear drop accentuates the mood. Very well done, Manny.
Post actions
Beautiful... nicely showed emotion... good capture of softness of skin... just light piece of sholder bit distract.
Post actions
Good take on the subject, great shades, and good photo.
Post actions
Composition: 9, Technical: 9, Appeal: 8, Challenge: 9, Overall Calculated Average Score: 9
Post actions
man. i just love this. i keep comeing back to it. i dont know if this is fake or what but the tears seem very real by the expression on her face. well done and a very good example of broken.
Post actions
This is top5 for me. Excellent executed. I hope you ribbon.
Post actions
Well done, although seems too sterilized for a broken heart. Where's the runny nose, the blotchy make-up, the million emotions? I'll give it a 7 because it's a great photo but I'm not convinced...
Post actions
I think this photo is beautiful. The tear does not look realistic.
Post actions
Good tones and conveying of the theme. -danny
Post actions
Nice capture, very emotive. Good luck.
Post actions
Great display of emotion!
Post actions
Interesting composition, nice lighting
Post actions
Excellent composition. I like the perspective and framing. The model is showing the appropriate emotions to make this one work. Technically aspects beyond reproach. Well done.
Post actions
There i s a specific sense of sadness in this photograph -- the clarity emphasizes the mood of brokenhearted -- a strong sense of distress.
Post actions
Know the feeling well. nice tones and use of B&W, subject matter is very good
brokenhearted
Add photograph to your favorites
Add photographer to your favorites
Photographer found comment helpful.
