Author Thread Comments Made During the Challenge
Post actions
I like this very narrow focus depth, and think that having too much in focus would take away the unfamiliar feel of the shot.
Post actions
I would have liked more DOF. I know, others will say it is just right. But I do like your photo. A 6
Post actions
So simple and so appealing. Great job. I love the shallow DOF letting the foreground and background just fade away.
Post actions
i would've liked a different color cast, i think - but good and creative idea.
Post actions
I hope people don't call you on shallow focus, it works here I think. The line is interesting, draws me in. This picture seems really familiar, hopefully just from the thumbs. (sorry if you get similar comments from me twice, I know I judged this already but somehow it came up again)
Post actions
Well done... like the colors just wish it would be bit sharper on the spot of focus.Message edited by author 2004-12-08 13:44:17.
Post actions
Love the dof, what is that noodles?
Post actions
Love the simplicity. Would have liked a little more DOF myself.
Post actions
more depth of field in the foreground would help, the foreground curve blends in with the out of focus parts
Post actions
shame more isnt in focus.
Post actions
love it. Maybe a bit more depth. nice detail and color.
Post actions
Post actions
I like the idea; I would play with focus and DOF differently, though.
Post actions
Nice and simple. I like it.
Post actions
This is so unique, I really like it. I wish there was a lot more DOF on this though.
Post actions
Very stylistic. I like the way you curved the spaghetti. I also like the depth of field used and the cropping is perfect. Just a couple of comments...I think this shot could have benefitted tremendously by a levels/curve adjustment to give this image a little more pop. Along the same lines, a hue/saturation adjustment could have really made this one stand out.
Post actions
Post actions
The dof is just too shallow and the image overall is very soft. if there was a really sharp area it would have been very cool
Post actions
I like the simplicity of this photo. Nice concept.
Post actions
the very shallow depth of field leaves nowhere for the eyes to go in the image... but I do love the idea
Post actions
i like idea. it is very different picture...8
Post actions
nice clean shot great image
Post actions
cool idea! the muted lighting adds to the impact.
Add photograph to your favorites
Add photographer to your favorites
Photographer found comment helpful.
