Author Thread Comments Made During the Challenge
Post actions
Great picture...as I'm sure you already know, it's too small.
Post actions
This is just the right sort of picture for black and white! It is a bit small and might have been more pleasing to the eye if there had been more sky left on top of the gree and to the right of the tree so the whole picture followed more closely the rule of thirds.
Post actions
This is a very interesting tree, but the image just a little too small.
Post actions
Post actions
technically speaking, i like to see a full range of value (at least one spot pure white, one pure black) i think your photo would be better if you increase both the brightness and contrast. it's also pretty small and hard to see the details. submit larger next time.
Post actions
Put the tree more off center, include more negative space.
Post actions
Would love to have seen a larger version of this entered in the challenge.
Post actions
what a cool tree and cool shot, it is so small though..i think the larger images are more impactful, i would make it 640 pixels max
Post actions
I would score this more highly if it were bigger. Difficult to appreciate the detail when it's this small.
Post actions
I like this shot, but it's too small and will suffer for it. 5
Post actions
Post actions
Too small, otherwise interesting subject. I would have left more space on the right.
Post actions
320 X 241? How about 640 x 482 so we can se it.
Post actions
Post actions
nice shot but not big enough
Post actions
This image has a lot of potential. You have found an interesting subject. I would like to see the tree a less centered. A little more space to the right and above would make it more appealing. Your image is also small and this might hurt your score.
Post actions
good subject, but it's pretty small.
Post actions
Too small, and using the rule of thirds would have greatly improved the composition.
Post actions
I'm sure everyone will say something along these lines, but I'll say it too: Picture looks great, but make it bigger! :)
Post actions
Would like to see more detail - photo is a bit small. Looks pretty nice, otherwise.
Post actions
nice shot but wish it was bigger
Post actions
Great picture! Its a very freaky tree. I am not skilled in this art, but I know what I like. The only but I find is that the picture is a bit off center.
Post actions
too small. needs to be about 600 pixels on a side
Post actions
Really nice, wish you had made it larger.
Post actions
F*cking great tree. I really wish the picture was bigger.
Post actions
Add photograph to your favorites
Add photographer to your favorites
Photographer found comment helpful.
