Author Thread
Post actions
It would have been the brown one if it was in color!
Post actions
yes you was unlucky not to get the brown ribbon.. my sympathys to you, better luck next time hehehehehe.
Post actions
WTF is this nonsense. If I'm gonna do horribly I might as well get the brown. Cmon, this was worse than that flowery one. Jeez. 2nd to last sucks.
Post actions
Thanks all. No, I was not going for the brown, it just happens naturally with me.
Comments Made During the Challenge
Post actions
not sure how this image wound up like this, but it is a little too grainy for me.
Post actions
Sorry are you going for the brown?
Post actions
It is tough to tell what he is doing since the hands can't be made out. The grain can be interesting, but might be toned back just a little.
Post actions
I can barely make out the image...terrible resolution.
Post actions
The image would be easier to see if it were larger and less grainy.
Post actions
Post actions
Too small, and the grainy effect really doesn't do it for me. (And if you hadn't added the noise, the image would have compressed much better, so you wouldn't have needed to crop it below 640!) 2
Post actions
you totally lost me here, sorry...................................
Post actions
sorry, quality is too poor here.Message edited by author 2004-11-24 12:13:11.
Post actions
More noise than it needs.
Post actions
Far too much grain. Subject is underexposed.
Post actions
Extremely grainy photo. Would recommend more light and a lower ISO setting.
Post actions
The grain muddies this picture too much. I am unsure what your subject is doing. I seems to have his hand out, but I am unsure if he is reaching for me or pushing me away. I am unable to see his facial expression to judge from theat either. Great idea, though. Change the angle and clean this up and you could really have a powerful image.
Post actions
Hmmm, not to sure 'bout this. Very grainy (intentional or not), very dark on the model and hard to distinguish...sorry...it doesn't work for me
Post actions
I don't understand what you were getting at with this photo. It is grainy distorted, and has no point
Post actions
Post actions
Photo is very small, and I know the grain effect is on purpose but I think it's way overboard. Too much detail and interest in your subject is lost.
Post actions
I really don't like the effect on this, or the subject to be honest.
Post actions
this is a gritty picture, but it works in this case, the back light also works, this is the opposite of "pro" but it really works for me... maybe if there could be more of the backlighting shinning on the top of his hat to fully uluminate his pose that would work a bit better, but good shot
Post actions
not sure what you were going for here but it doesnt work IMO, sorry
Post actions
Is this from a camera phone? The high ISO noise and tiny image size really make it difficult to enjoy this image.
Post actions
Going for the brown? you might just get it. too grainey no focus really looks like a webcam shot to me. I wish i could suggest something to help but i cant think of anything other than you try to remove the noise with photoshop or something.
Add photograph to your favorites
Add photographer to your favorites
Photographer found comment helpful.
