Author Thread
Post actions
Thanks for all the great comments...by the way, the shoes were a wreck just didnt come out that way with the contrast.
Post actions
Congrats on your top ten finish, Charmayne!
Post actions
congrats on your top ten great job
Post actions
Congratulations on your top 10. I wish it ended higher. FANTASTIC, but this one you know already.
Post actions
Wow. I'm so surprised and pleased to see that this photo scored well. I gave it a 10 and it's going in my favorites. Great work.
Post actions
I just loved this picture, i voted a 10
Comments Made During the Challenge
Post actions
The more I look, the more I like! I hope that the grain doesn't drag down your score, best of luck-
Post actions
Great picture, and the effect adds to it! Very photojournalistic!
Post actions
The chain in the upper left corner is too distracting. Love the grittiness of the photo.
Post actions
One of my favorites if this challenge 9
Post actions
Post actions
Real gritty picture, greatly lends to the chellenge. (solid 8)
Post actions
great contrast, I like it.
Post actions
why would someone challege the validity of this photo? and how do you get the grainy effect?
Post actions
Terrific shot, deserves an 8 for sure, might come back later and bump up...
Post actions
Looks like a litography. I like the composition and fantastic texture. 10.
Post actions
Post actions
Conveys the message well. I like the mono and the starkness it has eal impact. Well done.
Post actions
I really like what you did with this photograph. I hope you'll share how you did it when it's over.
Post actions
Incredible piece of work. Has to be a ribbon.
Post actions
I rate this for its gritty feel. Judging by the clothes and trainers, this is a setup shot, rather than a snatched shot. However, this doesn't detract from the overall harshness. I am glad you introduced noise cos Poverty is not a sharp, clean and refined subject, it's about the street and the grim. 10
Post actions
i like the grain and the limiting, it's refreshing to see a stand against the NeatImage'ers - well done
Post actions
In poverty are we not all up against a wall? I like this picture and all that it has to say. Good job.
Post actions
really great shot - I think I know who did this :-) Anyway, really nice..love the graffiti and the position of the body. 8
Post actions
the sneakers are too nice for a bum :)
Post actions
Hmmm... those look like some fancy sneakers.
Post actions
The shoes are not in character here - just gives the game away a little.
Post actions
This.. this lookes posed, to me anyway. I looke like a shot for an album cover of some sort. Yes it's a person laying in an alley way, but it looks like nice new shoes and jeans. With a jacket tossed over his head. Seems like a clean subject trying to look down and out.
Post actions
does not fit challenge in my opinion..oops, this one DOES fit the challenge I like it.
Post actions
Post actions
I think more about the style and treatment of this image rather than the message. There seems to be an intrinsic fault about it an allmst surreal feel which has taken over.
Post actions
very to the point.. and nice effects
Post actions
The noise/over-exposre/saturation detract, IMO.
Post actions
a little to contrasty for my taste but its still a nice shot
Post actions
This is definitely one of my top picks among all the entries. 9 and not a 10 for not moving the camera's angle of view downwards just slightly.
Add photograph to your favorites
Add photographer to your favorites
Photographer found comment helpful.
