Greetings from the Critique Club
Been a very long time since I did one of these, so I maybe a bit rusty.
I'm quite shocked to see this only scored 5.6 - I think it's a solid entry and your B&W conversion is good. I like the high contrast look. I suppose the lack of detail in the shadows is what pushed the score down a bit. The voting is at least pretty consistent.
I would have expected this to be much closer to a 6 than it is.
|