I think you got robbed... You only got a 4.9....Come on people this is better than that. I think that this is an awesome shot...and technically difficult to do. There are nice textures. The shot is very clean and crisp. All of this put together make a very nice shot. The only thing I can think of is you got some DNMC voters. Happy shooting.
I don't know how Ubique-Y this image may fall on the scale (if there is one), but I confess I always wanted to take a detailed moon photo like this one. I am always fascinated by objects in space.
It's quite striking. I have no idea if it's a good moon picture or not, because I know nothing about such matters. For me, pointing a camera up means I'm trying to get the battery out. It appears a good likeness, though. Very nicely lit, and I suspect you used only natural light, too. Thank you.