Author Thread Comments Made During the Challenge
Post actions
Some nice mystery. A 6 and a guess of 5.6
Post actions
A little bit dark for my tastes. i liked how the light fell on the table, but the light seemed uneven on the backdrop.
Post actions
The shadow and composition are nice but it leaves me a little flat. DPC will likely be a 5.0 IMO
Post actions
nobody is happy when the orange runs out, when orange starts to blend with its opposite. I predict 5.0000.
Post actions
The subject is clear but of little interest to me. Gave it a five and think your guess might be pretty close. 5.2
Post actions
Shot lacks much contrast and color although the composition is good. Likely score: 5.0
Post actions
Maybe 5.4. I think there's something about the white balance.
Post actions
Sounds pretty likely. 5.2
Post actions
A minimalist composition! I think the lack of elements, slightly messy wall, small submission size and slightly missed focus will add up in terms of voter penalty. I'm les optimistic than you. I guess 4.88.
Post actions
I don't really understand this photo. What is the message...what are you trying to show us and say? I think your looking at 4.7
Post actions
A very odd image. Oranges and ice outside on a table?
Post actions
Nice composition. For me more à 6
Post actions
This is among a relatively small number of images that I think will score well. 6.3
Post actions
A strange still life. I like it. 4.9
Post actions
I gave it a five. Guessing a 5.6.
Post actions
Fresh orange juice? Nice work on the glass and the light. 5.325
Post actions
you might be right. 5.2474.
Post actions
the fitful background is the main reason for me to stay under your guess - 4
Post actions
I think around 5.18 would be my guess, you are close I guess :)
Post actions
all drank up orange juice will score higher than your prediction at least 5.7 I really like what you've captured in the back ground with the wall texture and the wainscotting edge that looks like a metal band and I will vote it higher at seven, I always feel satisfied when I see this. Good Luck with your shot
Post actions
DPC voters will not like the complex textures on the back wall or the unglamorous contents of the vase. I am intrigued by both these things so will give you a six. DPC will give you 4.9
Post actions
Not enough to tell a story - 5.35
Post actions
Well composed shot - I like the semi transparent shadow and the little blue glow in the base. Better than your prediction I would think. Six from me, predict 5.633
Post actions
Trying to get some context here. A bit of a strange drink, it seems. 5.04
Post actions
what a day,,,,, so simple and beautiful photo,,,,, love it,,,, 6 from my house
Post actions
Post actions
I think you are pretty close with 5.2.
Post actions
Post actions
Post actions
Is it a drink? Looks gross. The wall behind is ugly. The light and shadow is nice I think the same as you 5.18
Post actions
hard to say.... sometimes less is more. but sometimes less Is Actually less.
Post actions
probably worth more than your title, I think 5.75
Post actions
Interesting composition, but it just isn't appealing to me. I like the lighting and textures on the wall and table, but the orange peel is off-putting. I'm guessing the voters won't get it either. 5.1
Post actions
I voted before looking at titles, now commenting.
Post actions
Well seen; possibly the only thing I might change would be the shadow along the top, if that were possible. Not the line, or the dot. Just the shadow. 6.17
Post actions
I voted a five, I will guess DPC will give a 4.6
Post actions
4.9652 (I gave it a five)
Post actions
Doesn't look the most appealing drink:) I estimate a final score of 4.9
Post actions
Hello, I voted a few days ago, now returning for comments. I think that you estimated your score a little low, I gave you a six but I think that you will finish at 5,3946
Post actions
simple still life done them myself and got 4.3618 !!
Post actions
I gave this a seven. The bar across the top is my favorite part but love the light and like the shapes and shadows. The colors are interesting. I predict 5.3.
Post actions
I know it's just an image and it doesn't have to make sense but I just don't get it. But it is oddly interesting.
Post actions
Add photograph to your favorites
Add photographer to your favorites
Photographer found comment helpful.
