Author Thread
Post actions
This just jumps out at you with the gorgeous colours and lighting. Congratulations on your top 10 image.
Comments Made During the Challenge
Post actions
I think you are close if not a bit low. 6.5
Post actions
I like the colors a lot. A six from me but I think a 5.8 from DPC
Post actions
Post actions
Great light and detail on the calla - color looks just a bit over-saturated and I want the rest of the leaf at the top - better yet, a leaf that bends back into the composition so you don't have to go higher but it's not cropped off. Gave this a seven, predicting about what you gave it. 6.2
Post actions
Beautiful curves. I sa 6.5
Post actions
Wonderful colors and clarity. I would have liked to see the whole pot though. 6.4
Post actions
I predict 6.3, has everything that voters like.
Post actions
Post actions
I like the focus on the flowers and not on the vase. I gave you a 6
Post actions
This is among a relatively small number of images that I think will score well. 6.3
Post actions
A symphony. Beautifully lit and composed. 6.3
Post actions
I gave it a six. Guessing a 5.8.
Post actions
Not enough going on here for many voters, I think they like it less than you do (and less than I do). I think you'll get something like 5.94.
Post actions
Great flowers and shapes! 6.16
Post actions
Oh we love pretty plants but I think the crop doesn't work well with the chopped off leaves and unbalanced dead space. My guess - about 5.58.
Post actions
oh, such a pity that the leaves are cut off! If you'd cut it even more boldly then it would have been better - 5 from me and I predict 5.9
Post actions
6.8 is my guess, I find that when i have a portrait style photo of an object like this one the crop should not eliminate a portion of the subject when you have total control. I love the colour and detail and your choice of background and I especially like the fill light. I think this is well done, this site is quite finicky with voters and we may have both under rated this shot… have I seen this before? my vote for this is nine Good Luck
Post actions
Post actions
This is lovely, great rich colors. Miss seeing the top of the leaf. 6.1
Post actions
no no,,,,to low,,,,,,ends in 6,6 ,, top 3 i hope,,,,, my final number is 9
Post actions
Nice light, texture, complimentary colors. Would like to see the ends of the leaves. 6.35.
Post actions
Post actions
It's beautiful and colorful, I don't like the leaves are cropped out. I don't think it score so high. Looking closer to a 5.7
Post actions
I like the fact this looks so much like a painting. great flowers and fantastic lighting
Post actions
Perfectly lit and wonderful subject. I think you have underestimated this. I would estimate the final score to be 7.1
Post actions
Stunning lighting. A tad busy with that back leaf for me to totally love. 9.
Post actions
striking shot, beautifully lit. predict 6.48
Post actions
It's processed well. But the dark shadow on the vase is a little distracting. and I don't like the crop that much. I think you've over estimated your score, going for around 5.78 instead.
Post actions
Beautiful colours against the dark background. Seven from me, predicting 6.405
Post actions
Oh no much better than that! Or at least I think it deserves higher! Love the colors and clarity. Great image! 6.7
Post actions
6.021 (I gave it a seven)
Post actions
I voted before looking at titles, now commenting.
Post actions
I voted a 6, I really love the color of the vase
Post actions
Technically well done. Good composition. I predict 6.0.
Post actions
A well-lit and colorful shot. The composition is fun but a bit flat IMHO. 6.0
Post actions
All elements are here: color, contrast, sharpness … and you might get the score you estimated
Post actions
I like how the lighting and pp has almost turned this into a painting. Lovely. Perhaps a crop off the top and left side would make the white flower less centred and result in a flowing effect from top left to bottom right. Although I've scored this much higher, I predict 6.32
Post actions
I like this shot and I think you're guess should be real close to the end result.
Post actions
yes you could be right on the button
Post actions
Hello, I voted a few days ago, now returning for comments. I think that you under estimated your final score a little bit, this is one of my top ten in this Challenge and I gave you an eight, I predict that you will finish at 6.689 and it should be a top ten.
Post actions
5 Just a personal take -- cumbersome.
Post actions
Post actions
I think it will perform better than you think, however not a being a fan of floral shots, it does get a 6 from me.
Add photograph to your favorites
Add photographer to your favorites
Photographer found comment helpful.
