Author Thread Comments Made During the Challenge
Post actions
My guess is your guess. We are uncomfortable with the slightest suggestion of warp. 5
Post actions
Take a guess! I enjoy the squeeze.. gets a six from me. DPC, I predict will be harsher... an optimistic 5.0
Post actions
I enjoy the distortion here - like the subject is being sucked into a vortex or crushed by cymbals. Gave it a five but predict a little lower for it - not as low as your guess, though. 4.8
Post actions
It's a cool bendy effect so I think it's gonna break 5.0
Post actions
5.3 prediction, 6 from me. Nicely seen.
Post actions
Fun portait but I would have liked a closer crop...to me the left and right edges, while explanatory, are distracting. 5.2
Post actions
Fun image but doesn't make me stop and look twice. Doesn't capture my attention
Post actions
I agree with your evaluation. 5 for me
Post actions
For me, this image is a good one, but a couple notches below the best images in the challenge. I expect it to do about 5.3
Post actions
Post actions
I gave it a five. Guessing a 5.6.
Post actions
Great distortion. I hope you get more and indeed I think you will. 5.42 (less than I gave you).
Post actions
Looks like a creative selfie in B&W. 5.1219
Post actions
Good expressionism but we don't like too much creativity here so I'll guess a 5.2317. My vote is a 6.
Post actions
pastime shooting? 4 from me and I predict 4.13
Post actions
Your score is about right :)
Post actions
This looks like an interesting reflection in a concave object. It has a lot of movement in the image my eye keeps moving. I'll agree with your guess of 4.2. Good Luck
Post actions
Lynch meets Tarkovskij - I like it but it's 5.30
Post actions
Hard to wrap my head around. 4.41
Post actions
so realistic and scary,,,,, looks like my principal,,,,,,so i have to give this 10,,,
Post actions
Distortion can be an interesting thing. 4.92
Post actions
Post actions
Nice try to do something different. Interesting except for the big white light. 4.8
Post actions
4.0213 (I gave it a four) It's not very interesting to me. Perhaps if there were more detail in the face... or it were in color... I don't know...
Post actions
I'm trying to figure out what you're using for the reflection and I can't come up with it...interesting to see if it's in notes
Post actions
i disagree. this is a good 'look carefully, look again' kinda shot. I gave it eight previously, now returning to update - final score prediction: 5.0
Post actions
Post actions
Interesting - definitely not in my four row. Six from me, predicting 5.643
Post actions
Like a fun house mirror- not my favorite of the challenge, but a good effort. 4.1
Post actions
I like the distortion in this. I give it a 5
Post actions
the abstract is kinda cool, but I thnk a little higher than that..I voted a five
Post actions
Like Alice down the rabbit hole... 5.37
Post actions
I voted before looking at titles, now commenting.
Post actions
You are probably close with your estimate but I will go a bit higher with 4.7
Post actions
Interesting stretched portrait. I gave it a six. I predict 5.0.
Post actions
5 Demonstrates the danger of approaching a black hole.
Post actions
You might be right
Post actions
Hello, I voted a few days ago, now returning for comments. I think that you estimated your score well, I gave you a four and I think that you will finish at 4,2498
Post actions
I like the sharp edges and the wonkyness but I don't think it's going to please the masses here.
Post actions
A little pestimistic I reckon low 5.1306
Add photograph to your favorites
Add photographer to your favorites
Photographer found comment helpful.
