Author Thread Comments Made During the Challenge
Post actions
I did not connect well with this image. I like the strength of the bottom tree, but the straight lines of the sky didn't seem to mesh with the movement of the rest of the image.
Post actions
I love skies but I don't love con trails. Gave it a five. Predict 4.7
Post actions
that would be nice. lovely subtle blend of branches and cloud patterns. the kind of photo we take all the time and which rarely zings as this one does. I predict 6.5. but vote 7
Post actions
I give this a six... so much to view and the trails are pretty special. DPC might come up with a 6 as well.
Post actions
interesting lines, nice contrast 5.5
Post actions
lol. Can't hurt to hope. I'm guessing 4.6
Post actions
Interesting. Optimistic. Maybe your first 5.8
Post actions
Very nice bw, will score a 5.7. So you got those numbers wrong.
Post actions
Thats a lot of vapor trails. This reminds me of an old horror series opening credits.
Post actions
I love the black and white and your composition but I give you 6 sorry
Post actions
For me, this image is a good one, but one notch below the best images in the challenge. I expect it to do about 5.8
Post actions
Nice how the textures blend. 5.7
Post actions
I gave it a six. Guessing a 5.9.
Post actions
Nice perspective but your optimism is up there with the clouds. I gave you a six but I think DPC will give you about 5.75.
Post actions
Nice division of the photo with all those lines. 5.175
Post actions
this is an interesting image full of lines and structures - I'm missing some colour - 6 from me, I predict 5.7
Post actions
I've never seen that many vapour trails at the same time, cool shot, I'm unsure of the trees right-side up and upside down too a lot going on here and quite busy contrast is high. composition is unique, I think black and white really helps out here, your score prediction is optimistic I guess lower at 6.3 but will give you a score of seven Good Luck
Post actions
A super amount of detail, an animal hide patterned expanse.6 is about the upper edge. Maybe I am wrong.
Post actions
You have to wait, this is a 5.50
Post actions
Seven from me, but I don't think you'll get to your title figure.
Post actions
yepp,,,,,,,,i hope so,,,,,coool shot,,,,,,,,,, 9 from me so your dream may come true
Post actions
Dramatic image. I guess 6.09
Post actions
Post actions
Lol 7.5 is an amazing score for an amazing picture. It's not bad and the composition is very interesting but it misses some power. 6.2
Post actions
if only we could pick our scores.
Post actions
... will not be in this challenge. I scored it seven and think it will get 6.2
Post actions
Post actions
speaks to me of the longing for travel. 5.67
Post actions
I voted before looking at titles, now commenting.
Post actions
I like it but more a 5 from me. It doesn't wow me
Post actions
Post actions
chem trails can look soo awesome, I bet DPC will vote a 4.6
Post actions
It will be interesting to see if predictions seem to affect scores. THis is interesting and is reminiscent of abstract compositions. My prediction is 5.53
Post actions
I can't quite work out what angle you took this from. I estimate a final score of 6.2
Post actions
Way over estimated, pretty sure you know that :)
Post actions
close, marked with … mark erased as per challenge rule
Post actions
Looks like the jet trails are raining down.
Post actions
probability of a 7 low more 5.786
Post actions
I gave this a seven but seven point five would not be too high. Love all of the diagonals, at both ends of the tonal spectrum. Almost as if they are reaching for each other. I predict 5.6.
Post actions
Hello, I voted a few days ago, now returning for comments. I think that you over estimated your final score, even if this is one of my top five in this Challenge and I gave you a eight, I predict that you will finish at 6.369 and it should be a top ten.
Post actions
5.4 Too needlessly busy for my taste. Also, the contrails don't add anything, in my opinion.
Post actions
Love the drama of the B and W 8
Add photograph to your favorites
Add photographer to your favorites
Photographer found comment helpful.
