Author Thread Comments Made During the Challenge
Post actions
good view with miraculous light. I predict 5.1.
Post actions
The light is lovely, focus is good but not great, I like the composition very much. Gave it a six. I think Mom's more than a little optimistic - you've been at this longer. Guessing 6.
Post actions
Nice view but a bit too hazy. I agree with all of you except your DPC which I guess will be a 5.5.
Post actions
I think it might break 6.0
Post actions
I think it's DPC: 5.83 (although mom knows best). Unfortunately, with the new image sizes, portrait orientation is severely disadvantaged against the huge landscape formats. Plus, they will complain about the tilt to the right.
Post actions
Post actions
I love the perspective...what may hurt it a bit is the subdued colors and what looks like a small tilt (which is probably just perspective. I think you're looking at about 6.1
Post actions
Too far away to be overly interesting.
Post actions
I agree with your evaluation I give you a 6
Post actions
For me, this image is a good one, but one notch below the best images in the challenge. I expect it to do about 5.5
Post actions
Post actions
I gave it a seven. Guessing a 6.4
Post actions
Moms are wonderful, aren't they? I would have liked it better as a landscape view, but still I think you're prediction is accurate. I'll guess 5.84.
Post actions
A fine representation of the scene but it may take more to appeal to many. I suspect your DPC estimate is still a little high - I'd guess 5.66.
Post actions
Wonderful city view with the white building in the foreground. Not happy with the colors here. 5.84
Post actions
I like the viewpoint. You made a very accurate guessing - I'd go for that!
Post actions
I think your mom is very wise. this has great depth of field and is sharp all the way through. It has great color,I Like that sky it is great! good job here I agree withe your speculation of 5.74 Good Luck
Post actions
So much information here. It is like 2 or 3 images in one. I think for the DPC crowd, it needs some more post-processing but would work great for national Geographic or something. 5.972 prediction
Post actions
Well I don't think Mom's right, but I think your own valuation is reasonable and I'll go along with that 6.38 as my prediction too. I have given you 7
Post actions
jeee dpc is tough ,,,,, but probably true close to 5,6+
Post actions
Post actions
Post actions
A little more clarity, and contrast would be a good thing here. The overall light is very dull as well. The offset comp creates a "snapshot" feeling. My estimate is 5.45. Sorry!
Post actions
Oh Mom. You think everything we do is a 10.
Post actions
Sky is too different from the rest of the image. No doubt this is good stuff but a slightly different editing could improve this image. My prediction - 6.10
Post actions
The shot is nice but I do not feel it interesting, 5.65
Post actions
Wow that is a multi-layered treat to the eyes. I estimate a final score of 6.0
Post actions
Nice capture of the Griffith Observatory with a very compelling sky. 5.9
Post actions
I voted before looking at titles, now commenting.
Post actions
I am between you and mom. This is lovely. A 6 from me
Post actions
Nice perspective / composition, with a nice arrangement of elements to lead your eye through the shot. 5.79
Post actions
Post actions
This is really pretty, I love the pink tones, I think DPC will give ya 5.1
Post actions
Nice layered effect. I predict 5.5.
Post actions
YOU're the photographer ... YOU should know best! I like this... the pinks and greens work well. I gave a seven but I guess 6.2
Post actions
5.2 I find the sky to be the most interesting part of this image.
Post actions
I gave you a 6, not a big fan of cityscapes, but having said that it's done well, and most DPC'ers love this sort of stuff, so I'm thinking maybe 6.20.
Post actions
You gave us too many variables so I won't venture any guessing
Post actions
Mom is a generous person and I guess like all moms she knows best but I am more conservative 6.213
Post actions
Hello, I voted a few days ago, now returning for comments. I think that you estimated your score very well, but not your mom...;) lol, I first gave you a six and now raising it to seven, I predict that you will finish at 6,2477
Post actions
I like how this building pops out from the rest of the image.
Post actions
I really like the background and how the subject pops out from the background. My 4th favourite. 7
Add photograph to your favorites
Add photographer to your favorites
Photographer found comment helpful.
