Author Thread Comments Made During the Challenge
Post actions
worth at least a 6, which is my guess. 7
Post actions
Hope your hopes were not too high. I like the child and dog all right, not so much all the rest of the stuff. Gave it a five but predict a 4.8.
Post actions
Two pals. Sweet shot. Your score five.0? My guess is higher, 5.9.
Post actions
A girl and her dog! I'm not getting a strong statement from this image, I'm guessing it will only do so so. 5.1
Post actions
Since the image number was 5052, I'm gonna go with 5.052
Post actions
She sneaked in Sherlock's room. Love the ambitious choice of title :-). Prediction 5.8, some might complain about composition. I think it works very well, 8 from me, I really like this.
Post actions
Title's going to hurt you here, but it's a nice capture. I do think they're a bit far down in the frame (seems cut off at the bottom). 6.0
Post actions
that globe looks good enough to eat. I love the chunkiness of it. DPC will like the girl and the dog in that wonderful relaxed and loving pose, but they won't like how small they are in the frame and they won't like that your title doesn't have a guess in it, even though it does. I like small subjects with rich backgrounds. This is a six from me. 5.052
Post actions
Very sweet image
Post actions
Post actions
For me, this image is a good one, but one notch below the best images in the challenge. I expect it to do about 5.5
Post actions
An action packed frame in spite of the sleepy subject. Nice grain. 5.8
Post actions
Unpretentiously natural and calming domestic scene. So what's your guess? Mine is a 5.95 and my vote is a seven.
Post actions
I gave it a six. Guessing a 5.6.
Post actions
I like this quite a bit. I estimate about 6.18
Post actions
Nice combination of the kid and the dog. 4.83
Post actions
you should have put more emphasis on child and dog and how cozy their couch is. Everything else is distracting - 4 from me
Post actions
Nice family shot, but they don't notice you, especially the Dog, nice natural light. I can't agree with your score guess as I don't know what it is. I guess a 5 here, Good Luck
Post actions
It's about to tell a story but it lacks it. Nice but could have been better - 5.90
Post actions
This is quite a charming slice of life and I'm hoping that your prediction proves to be a bit pessimistic. Six from me and a prediction of 6.1075.
Post actions
this ends in 5,5+ lot lower,,,
Post actions
Post actions
Post actions
Post actions
nice feeling but weird composition. 5.2
Post actions
cute kid,like the dog, but honestly feel would be a better shot if it was lower and zoomed on them more
Post actions
Dang - love the warm fuzziness of this - sorry there isn't a title but I'm giving a seven!
Post actions
I voted before looking at titles, now commenting.
Post actions
Post actions
Post actions
Post actions
Like a cherished snapshot in a family's photo album this is an innocently sweet, homey, feel-good quality image. Poignantly intimate. Perfect B&W.
Post actions
I like viewing this moment and passing on.Thnak you.
Post actions
Quiet. Could have been found in a roll of old negatives of a prominent photographer. 5.97
Post actions
Nice processing. Cute scene. I predict 6.8.
Post actions
5.2 In my opinion, a tight crop somewhere in the lower right quadrant would make this into a fine image.
Post actions
Post actions
Nice relaxing shot. B&W works well in my opinion. I estimate this will score 5.7
Post actions
Sweet image of a child resting with her dog, but too much of a snap shot to be interesting beyond another level, maybe 5.20.
Post actions
This is a real slice of life image and I quite like it. My preference would perhaps be to crop off the bright edges that compete for my attention and possibly play with the processing to draw more attention to the child and the dog in this busy scene. I scored you higher than: 5.82
Post actions
I don't think that you guessed a score so I can't put my 2 cents of prediction either
Post actions
I like the "slice of life" shots. Just a tad grainy for my taste.
Post actions
Hello, I voted a few days ago, now returning for comments. First, the picture does not meet the challenge as you had to title the image with the score you expect to receive. I gave you a three and because of the DNMC you might get lots of ones, so I think that you will finish at 3,1586
Post actions
I think this cosy little scene should be in the middle 5s perhaps a bit higher
Add photograph to your favorites
Add photographer to your favorites
Photographer found comment helpful.
