Author Thread Comments Made During the Challenge
Post actions
This one has so much more potential imo. Most notably I would crop the right figure off and lighten the face so we can see his expression better. As it is, I can imagine. Gave it a five but maybe I'll come back to bump. Predict 5.75
Post actions
a sveldt mannequin flaunts its androgyny in the town of the foreshortened. What were you thinking? Your guess is mine, but this should be worth more.
Post actions
This one made me think, but after several viewings am still uncertain about the headless mannequin.... it could really use a straightening too! 5.1
Post actions
I think that's right on the money with 5.1
Post actions
My guess is 5.45. I'm giving you a 6, I like the moment of hesitation.
Post actions
Seems a bit dark (especially the main character) and a bit tilted (may be lens based distortion though). I love the captured moment though! 6.25
Post actions
Post actions
I think the grainy, noisy look is perfect for this image.
Post actions
I love black and white and this photograph is very nice. For me 6
Post actions
For me, this image is a good one, but a couple notches below the best images in the challenge. I expect it to do about 5.5
Post actions
Oh, what a trinity. It will be lost on so many. 4.9
Post actions
Great candid street capture. I have to believe this will do better and guess a 5.79. It's a seven from me.
Post actions
I gave it a six. Guessing a 5.6.
Post actions
I really get a sense of the place here but faces left in the dark and a bit of grain/noise tend not to be things the DPC collective reward. I suspect you are about right - I go for 5.13
Post actions
Nice street photo with a story. 5.23
Post actions
I might be biased, but this is worth a lot more in my book (were a random street threesome is way harder than a pair). I suspect the grain would deduct some pointage by some, but I won't accept anything less that 5.8763 (just because you sold yourself short).
Post actions
Post actions
Nice moment, but it's too dark and too much out of balance for my taste
Post actions
Nice Street shot! the capture was at the perfect moment when he was doing an extended or double take. I agree with the choice for B&W, it often works well for these types of shots. The depth of field is good with great focus through out. I think your score expectation is a wee bit low but I'll agree with the 5.12, I hope its higher! Good Luck
Post actions
With a square crop this would get a better score. Now it's 5.90
Post actions
I like the humour in this candid capture. I might have cropped out the figure on the right to strengthen the focus on the man eyeballing the mannequin. It's a pity there is not a little more light on his face. Six from me, predicting 5.6205
Post actions
Gave it a 6, would have scored higher with some perspective correction
Post actions
Stark contrasts, but looking closer...actually the two have things in common. No arms and no fingers. Love the red hot chilly peppers too! Your estimate is too low. 5.99
Post actions
well there is cool shot,,,,,my guess is 5,3 +,,,,
Post actions
Post actions
This is a "caption it contest" shot if I have ever seen it. you might get a 5.5, but I gave it an 8.
Post actions
interesting slice-of-life.
Post actions
I like it 7 from me but I think 5,0
Post actions
I voted before looking at titles, now commenting.
Post actions
Love the look on his face. Much better than 5 I gave it a 6
Post actions
LOL I will meet your match of the 5.1, I love how he is looking at that maniquin, I voted a five
Post actions
Excellent handling of the vastly different lighting in this image. 5.84
Post actions
Post actions
Curious enough.. I gave a six for the looks. But I think this will end at 5.2 because voters don't particularly enjoy edgy.
Post actions
Hot pants! I estimate 5.7
Post actions
Could be a discussion in an art class that could go in so many directions. Love it. I score an eight. DPC will give it a 5.72
Post actions
Something doesn't work here in my opinion - I might have cropped the left side - but who knows how the majority appreciates?! I can venture a guess of 5.2
Post actions
Did he get a pair of those chili panties?
Post actions
good street shot but I think mid to high 5s going by past photos I think 5.456
Post actions
Hello, I voted a few days ago, now returning for comments. I think that you estimated your score a little high, I gave you a five and I predict that you will finish at 4,7774
Post actions
I wish to see the man's face and expression more. unclear but strong picture. It will score higher than your guess and I think a final score of 5.7 should be nice
Post actions
Bit of an interesting scene. Could be straightened and cropped a bit. Maybe a bit underexposed? 5
Post actions
6 Good reason to visit town.
Post actions
this is better than low 5s I reckon. nice street photograph. might be improved if the man on the far right was cropped out.
Post actions
Great story going on with this street shot 7
Add photograph to your favorites
Add photographer to your favorites
Photographer found comment helpful.
