Author Thread
Post actions
Great b&w and great leading lines.
Comments Made During the Challenge
Post actions
I guess 4.3. It is interesting.
Post actions
Good photo that would have been better in color., maybe with a star filter. But that's my opinion so I think your prediction is close. 6.23
Post actions
Nicely balanced - the light in places like this is never easy. Could use a bit more focus on the altar, I think. Gave it a six but your guess might be about right. 6.2
Post actions
Nicely done. Good guess too at 6.23
Post actions
Post actions
Prediction 6.3. Great tones and detail, 7 from me.
Post actions
I don't think it will be that high. It feels a little tilted and people who like this kind of shot want eye candy, which is in color. 5.6
Post actions
I think B&W works here and agree with your guess
Post actions
For me, this image is a good one, but one notch below the best images in the challenge. I expect it to do about 5.8
Post actions
Clean, great depth, eerily silent. 5.9
Post actions
I gave it a seven. Guessing a 6.2.
Post actions
Nice enough church scene - I think the lack of people restricts its narrative potential. I think your score will be more like 5.78, although it would do really well in a church-themed challenge.
Post actions
Very nice symmetric view of this church. 5.6312
Post actions
Good architectural shot of a lovely old church. Agree with your 6.23.
Post actions
Bit to high for me, I'm going with 5.85
Post actions
very well choosen exposure and great sharpness, 7 from me, predict a final score of 6.1
Post actions
This shot draws me as a viewer right in, its actually quite powerful. The B&W seems to work to maintain that draw, great DOF. good composition and light control
Post actions
Elegant BW and good lines - 6
Post actions
It's nice enough, the symmetry is great, and architecture often does well, but I'm not blown away by this. But that could be me ;-) I did score it higher than your guess. My score guess: 6.38
Post actions
Lovely light and perspective. 6.11
Post actions
6,23 is bit high i think,,, think 5,8+ we se soooon,,,,,,, 6 from me,,,
Post actions
Beautiful church and nice pov. A 6
Post actions
Great centered comp. Lots of interesting things to look at. 5.85
Post actions
Post actions
hard to say, but I figure this will get a 6.0053
Post actions
I think colors would be better. Did you do a lens correction? 6.04
Post actions
I like the composition and the black and white works very well to me. 7 from me.
Post actions
good exposure and processing. I'm going to do my part to get you past the tile score. prediction: 6.34
Post actions
Post actions
Interesting architecture and nice leading lines. Six from me, predicting that your own prediction, 6.23, is about right.
Post actions
excellent black and white treatment - feels very austere. 6.12
Post actions
5.75 - I like the perspective on this image and the beautiful tones in the B&W
Post actions
Post actions
I voted before looking at titles, now commenting.
Post actions
Wonderful symmetry and I like the b/w processing. I gave and guess a six and a 6.
Post actions
I did give this a 6, The details are really nice as well as the lighting for this being in black and white, very calming
Post actions
Nice processing. I predict 5.8.
Post actions
5.8 Well done and with very nice tones. The urge to do such an interior symmetrically is understandable, but it's also rather static.
Post actions
Nice composition and lighting and leading lines to the front. I estimate 5.7
Post actions
Post actions
nice internal shot of a nice church good for holiday album I think 5.546
Post actions
Hello, I voted a few days ago, now returning for comments. I think that you estimated your score a little high, I gave you a six and I predict that you will finish at 5,9682
Post actions
I like the depth but it leaves me wanting to see the details of the background objects.
Post actions
Nice and wide and sharp, decent exposure. 6
Post actions
Beautifull and very nice black and white. 7
Add photograph to your favorites
Add photographer to your favorites
Photographer found comment helpful.
