Author Thread
Post actions
Comments Made During the Challenge
Post actions
Post actions
I give you a 5, and good luck! Good image that I think would be better in color. 6, maybe 7 if the colors were good. Overall? I predict 5.9.
Post actions
Nice shot - not easy to get. A little soft for a great portrait. Gave it a seven. I think your guess is more realistic. 6
Post actions
I predict a 5.4. I would try to separate the bird from the background in the bw conversion.
Post actions
I like this image, I just wish the feathers were as crisp as the branch. 6.1
Post actions
Post actions
Very good bird capture. Nice BW but I think these type of shots are better in color, personally. Seems like your guess is good. 6.0
Post actions
I think the softness, lack of color and undramatic composition will lead to a lower score. 5.64
Post actions
Post actions
Wish this was in color
Post actions
I love the black and white. For me 7
Post actions
For me, this image is a good one, but one notch below the best images in the challenge. I expect it to do about 5.8
Post actions
Post actions
Good catch of a predator who seems to have caught you too. Should be a 6.2 or higher. Seven from me.
Post actions
I gave it a five. Guessing a 5.6.
Post actions
Well executed bird shot, could be a tad sharper for the audience that likes these shots, but I agree with your score: 6.0
Post actions
Post actions
nice, but too little contrast for your b+w choice. Maybe colour would work better?
Post actions
Interesting shot of a Hawk I guess maybe a Broad winged, hard to say I guess it could be a Merlin. Good focus with a nicely blurred background, I haven't seen many B&W Bird shots, I hope it does well. I will agree with a 6.0 here and vote at seven. Good Luck
Post actions
yes dont mess with this guy,,,,,6+
Post actions
The bar is high for wildlife photos these days. I guess 5.4
Post actions
Very nice shot. I think you are pretty close with 6, but I estimate 5.95.
Post actions
Post actions
I like it, but I am guessing 5.78
Post actions
The toning is flat, power it up with more contrast. 5.5
Post actions
nice contrast on the feathers, but the bg is a bit off, overall, for my taste.
Post actions
Post actions
spot on! I love a raptor and I love a blurry background. predict 5.81
Post actions
Quite a pleasant conversion to black and white for this bird image.
Post actions
Nice tones, detail and composition. Seven from me, predicting 6.566.
Post actions
Oh those feathers look so very soft - lovely mono conversion to retain that softness yet provide sharp where required. Nice. 5.99
Post actions
I voted before looking at titles, now commenting.
Post actions
Nice black and white of this bird. I give it a 7
Post actions
Probably not easy to shoot. Sharp and great bokeh. guessing 5.92
Post actions
When I'm in front of an image like this I want colors and it screams colors. It's a good photo, but I guess your prediction will be right - 6.00
Post actions
Post actions
I did vote this a 6
Post actions
Now what? Yes, probably 6
Post actions
Nice capture. I predict 5.5.
Post actions
6.2 because it´s beautiful
Post actions
Nice looking bird. I estimate 5.6
Post actions
Wel caught but no means a high scorer 5.245 sorry but its about what mine get!!
Post actions
Hello, I voted a few days ago, now returning for comments. I think that you estimated your score a little high, I gave you a six but I predict that you will finish at 5,7156
Post actions
Cool shot but there is something about the bokeh that makes the background very distracting.
Post actions
5 Uninteresting pose - the foremost branch cuts off the bottom of the raptor's body, leaving a bowling pin-like impression. Also, the background bokeh is distracting.
Post actions
Add photograph to your favorites
Add photographer to your favorites
Photographer found comment helpful.
