Author Thread Comments Made During the Challenge
Post actions
Boring to me - like our winter. Sorry. Gave this a four and I don't think you'll get much more. 4.25
Post actions
Curiosity awakened. I like this a lot, but it might end up at 5.1.
Post actions
Simple and perhaps subtle. The lack of focus will put many off though. I guess 4.1
Post actions
Nice idea, but to me, not enough there and a bit too soft. 4.5
Post actions
Post actions
It's interesting how some shots of nothing offend me and some please me. I think it's when the nothing is pretending to be something that I am offended, because so much of the world is like that. But it's refreshing to see nothing allowed to be nothing, which in turn reveals its potential to become something. Six from me, and from DPC you are right on the money. 4.3
Post actions
No very interesting.
Post actions
yooo,,,, this ends round 4,0-4,3 5 big one from me,,,,
Post actions
Nice negative space. 5 for me
Post actions
somehow I'm missing a motif. Hmm, 3 from me and I forecast 4.4
Post actions
Not enough detail in the dark areas IMHO. I expect it will finish 5.0
Post actions
Post actions
I gave it a five. Guessing a 5.6.
Post actions
Looks like 4.3 inches of snow. 4.13
Post actions
Yes we don't like such well-seen tri-tone minimalism here, but I guess a bit higher, maybe like a 5.0. I'm giving a 6 vote myself.
Post actions
Probably right. I like looking under that hedge though, and contemplating the prefect crease in the snow's trousers.(7 from me)
Post actions
I will agree with this score of 4.3 it may be a bit low might go a little higher but it has no real defined subject other than the snow drift which is a great snow drift & well lit but a little common or regular to stand out and catch the eye, the background is lacking definition as a result of the very ricky exposure with snow. I will vote a five here Good Luck
Post actions
Winter drags ... Nice minimal approach. 4.49
Post actions
interestingly simple. I say 4.6
Post actions
Post actions
Probably right on the mark, 4.32
Post actions
not to offend, but I feel dpc will likely reverse your numbers to a 3.4
Post actions
I think that a shot like this is not very interesting with the tones like this. Get pure white and more detailed on the trees behind and it would score much higher. a 5 from me and I guess a final score of 4.6
Post actions
4.0212 (I gave it a four) For me, something needs to be in focus.
Post actions
I like the simplicity of this. Six from me, predicting a score of 5.6
Post actions
pretty snow bank, just not very interesting. 4.2
Post actions
Not much to this. I give it a 4
Post actions
It doesn't impress me. I can only save the composition. Your prediction is not far from what you will get - 4.50
Post actions
Although I am a big fan of negative space, for me the 'positive' space holds little interest. 4.32
Post actions
I voted before looking at titles, now commenting.
Post actions
I will guess your vote at a 4.5
Post actions
4.3 that also my guess of the majority
Post actions
snow glorious snow and background - like the layers. Gave it a seven for the composition and abstractness but agree that this will end around 4.3.
Post actions
Looks a bit dull and flat and I don't find it that interesting but others may love it. I estimate 4.5
Post actions
Ok, well yes I would say you are right!~
Post actions
Post actions
Hello, I voted a few days ago, now returning for comments. I think that you estimated your score well, I gave you a four and I think that you will finish at 4,2498
Post actions
I gave this an eight. Love the simplicity and tones. I predict you sill get 4.8.
Post actions
I have to admit this is not one of my favorites.
Post actions
Good crop but I find it a bit uninteresting. 4
Post actions
Post actions
about right. but do I vote to see your guess fulfilled or vote to try and ensure it isn't? I'll do the right thing and vote it's worth to me. 3.
Post actions
looks like one of mine will score like one of mine 5+
Add photograph to your favorites
Add photographer to your favorites
Photographer found comment helpful.
